My Websites
Official Beatles sites
Other Websites
- Archer Valerie Beatles pages
- Beat Gear Cavern
- BeatleLinks
- Beatles History
- Beatles International
- Beatles Pics
- Beatles Wiki
- BeatleSource
- BeatlesTube
- Bill Harry's Mersey Beat
- Bootlegzone
- Demonoid
- Fab Guitars
- Fab News
- Hunger City
- MopTops Guide to the Beatles
- Reunion sessions
- Solo Beatles Photos Forum
- Steve at Examiner.com
- The Beatles Interviews Database
- The Beatles on DVD
- What Goes On?
- Yellow Sub (France)
Featured post
The Daily Beatle
This is a website about all things Beatle. There will be news if we find them attractive, there will also be articles and features about sol...
Followers
Total Pageviews
Archives
Find Us On Facebook
Blogs
-
Hickory Hill - John and Yoko visit Ethel Kennedy at her home, Hickory Hill in Virginia in May of 1972. Is that Rosie Greer?
-
McCartney & Wings – One Hand Clapping – It’s Official + Pack Shots - Six days after the news mistakenly slipped out, Paul McCartney has officially announced the release of audio from the 1974 live studio performance called O...
-
JOHN LENNON's GUITAR UP FOR AUCTION AFTER DISCOVERY IN ATTIC AFTER 50 YEARS - Julien’s Auctions announced Tuesday, April 23 that Lennon’s Framus 12-string Hootenanny acoustic guit...
-
LIBB P768: 22 April 2024 - Show 1461 Panel: Graeme Dickenson, Gavin Myers, Jo MacCarthy *LIBB Show 1461 WynFM Podcast P768* Download Or Stream LIBB Show 1461 WynFM Podcast P768 ...
-
Feel your own pain – John’s ‘Plastic Ono Band’ demos - When a deluxe edition of John’s classic John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band album was first seriously mooted back in 2020, I was curious to see how deep they coul...
-
Restored Let It Be film coming to Disney+ 05-08-24 - The Beatles’ 1970 film Let It Be is coming to Disney+ on 8 May 2024. The film, directed by Michael Lindsay-Hogg in January 1969, has been commercially un...
-
Having a Large Time! - I’m still working on the manuscript, but I just got the proof for the cover for my upcoming book about Southern music, and I’m very pleased with how it tur...
-
Harry Benson : « Paul » livre l'intimité de McCartney - C’est en 1964 que Harry Benson commence à photographier le jeune Paul McCartney, année charnière pour les Beatles qui déferlent sur l’Amérique, sillonnen...
-
-
ED治療の際はシルデナフィルの使い方を正しくマスターしよう! - シルデナフィルはED治療によく使用されていますが、使い方を間違えると命に関わることもありますので注意が必要です。一番良い方法は、医師や薬剤師など専門家に相談し、指示を守って服用することですが、ここでは一般的に言われているシルデナフィルの正しい使い方についてご紹介します。 市販されているシルデナフィルには25...
-
William Leslie Anthony (Les Anthony): 30 April 1933 - 21 May 2020. - Les Anthony, John's driver from 1965-1971, has died. The story goes that John was having problems finding a suitable chauffeur, and so Brian Epstein, upo...
-
The Decca Tapes - First Time In Stereo (By Lord Reith) - BITRATE: FLAC TRACK LISTING: Money The Sheikh Of Araby Memphis, Tennessee Three Cool Cats Sure To Fall September In The Rain Take Good Care Of My Baby Till...
-
The Final Beatles' Recording Session - On April 01 1970, final work was done on three of the tunes for the upcoming "Let It Be" (formerly known as "Get Back") project. The session was held in St...
-
There are seven levels. - [image: giphy (4)]
-
-
Bitcoin and Other Donations - Hello fellow Beatle-people! I have not been idle but been working on many things including the promised book for Comprehensive Beatles. I hope to have new...
-
-
-
-
Beatles Rarity of the Week – “Act Naturally” (Ringo Starr duet with Cilla Black, 1971) - Welcome to the Beatles Rarity of the Week. On August 1st, 2015 long-time Beatles-friend and fellow Liverpudlian Cilla Black (real name Priscilla Maria Vero...
-
-
-
Translate
Popular Posts
-
The Beatles' "Long Tall Sally" EP, featuring a photo of The Beatles in Sweden. Ok, so we brougth you a survey of the most ...
-
"Pure McCartney" is a new 2CD or deluxe 4CD compilation of previously released songs. So the news are out...er somewhat. I gue...
-
George Harrison Video Collection By Mike Carrera A fan recently asked which was the best Harrison “promo clip compilation” and my resp...
-
From the photo session: The Beatles with Adam, the son of photographer Michael Cooper. If you're looking for news about the upcoming...
-
The Sunday Times: Anniversary re-release of "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club band" due. According to The Sunday Times, a ...
-
The Beatles in Madrid (the photos, that is) Okay, we fell for it, hook, line and sinker. It was after all, a good story with a beautiful...
-
LET IT BE In a new interview with Cinematographer Tony Richmond, who worked on the "Let It Be" film under director Michael Lin...
-
Get your tickets for a special recording session with Sir Paul at BBC Maida Vale Studios! The radio series Mastertapes returns to BBC R...
-
Record store in Amsterdam From Monday to Friday last week, I've been in Amsterdam in Holland. And that's where I was when the ne...
Video Of Day
Our Shop
Statistics
About Us
This website is all about The Beatles and the individual members of The Beatles. It is kept by Roger Stormo, who has been associated with the Norwegian Beatles fan club, "Norwegian Wood", since 1980. Feel free to quote from the site, but please give me credit and a link back to the original item. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This is not a news site per se, but if we hear about something that has yet to be reported by other Beatles news services, we tend to write about it. Apart from that, we will write stuff about the Beatles on an irregular basis at the whim of the author. A lot of our readers arrive at specific articles from internet searches or references to this site from forums and other Beatles sites. If you did, we encourage you to click here to access the main page, and also to indulge in our archives - you may find other posts that are interesting. You may also subscribe to news from the site and have each new issue delivered to your rss feed reader.
This is not a begging letter... but feel free to support me by donating money! It'll keep me in business... Or just buy a t-shirt! Or take a look at my Amazon wish list...If you have Beatles related product to push, feel free to send us a copy, the address is:
Roger Stormo
Baglergata 21B
NO-2004 Lillestrøm
NORWAY
email: roger.stormo@gmail.com
We can't promise that your product will be featured on the site, but it stands a better chance than the ones we don't get...
Mobile site
Move over, Ms L!
Monday 25 January 2010
Why McCartney Can Never Win
Back in 2002 there was a lot of controversy, stirred up by Yoko Ono, about Paul McCartney's way of writing the composer's credits on his concert releases Back in the U.S. CD, the international version Back in the World and the DVD version. The "Lennon - McCartney" songs were credited "Composed by Paul McCartney and John Lennon". You'd think that was a pretty accurate way of putting it, but someone in the media thought that this was "tampering" with the original positioning of the names. They thought it should be "Lennon-McCartney", like it used to be on the old Beatles records. Yoko got wind of this, and had her lawyers "look into it". Lots of people sided with Yoko on this, and I wrote an article chronicling the events, trying to set the story straight.
In 1969, when John Lennon released his single, "Give Peace A Chance", he decided to put "Lennon - McCartney" as composers. McCartney really had nothing to do with this composition, just as Lennon had no input into the song "Yesterday" four years earlier, it was just that they used to put both names on any composition made by one or the other of them.
In 1998, Yoko Ono released a compilation of John Lennon's best known songs, called Lennon Legend: The Very Best of John Lennon. "Give Peace A Chance" was naturally a part of this CD, but this time the song was credited like this: "written by John Lennon". In 2003, a DVD of the same name was released, with the same credit for "Give Peace A Chance". In 2006, a documentary called The U.S. vs. John Lennon was released, with "Give Peace A Chance" again making an appearance, once again credited only to John Lennon.
In 1990, McCartney performed a version of "Give Peace A Chance" in Liverpool, which was then made available as a bonus track on a CD-single. The medley of "Strawberry Fields Forever"/"Help!"/"Give Peace A Chance" was credited to Lennon-McCartney on that release. The medley was only performed a few times during that tour.
In 2008, again in Liverpool, McCartney revived "Give Peace A Chance", this time in a medley with "A Day In The Life". Yoko Ono was in the audience that day. The medley has been kept as part of the set list in McCartney's live performances ever since. When McCartney released his new live DVD+CD Good Evening New York City, he must have taken notice of Yoko's removal of his name on those Lennon releases from 1998/2003 and 2006, because the credit there now reads "written by John Lennon".
Imagine my surprise when I read in a Beatles forum that one fan thought this was "rude of McCartney, trying to distance himself from the song"!
To me, this kind of reaction proves that whatever McCartney does, he can't ever win. It's like Sting says, History will teach us nothing.
5 comments:
Exactly. It never ceases to amaze me how McCartney is constantly accused of being manipulative -- as if Lennon and Yoko weren't masters of the art. Frank Zappa has a good story about how Lennon and Yoko robbed him of credit on a song but no one seems to remember that, and somehow McCartney is always the bad guy.
Wait. You admit that Paul has personally and publicly accepted the J.L. only credit for Give Peace a Chance -- how do you know that Paul didn't actively agree to that change? What makes you think that Yoko didn't contact Paul in advance, and he gave his blessing? I'd very genuinely like to know. Because this strikes me as the most logical explanation.
Right now, as is my understanding, it seems that we have no one's version of this particular story, and everything we say is pure speculation. And I really, really hate to see people vilified on speculation right now.
I don't see whether or not Yoko and Paul have made an agreement about how to write the composer's credits on "Give Peace A Chance" has anything to do with my point. The point is, whatever McCartney does, someone will always question his motives.
And my point is that whatever Yoko does, her motives will be questioned even more. And I don't think that implying that Yoko did something wrong by removing Paul's name from GPaC, as you did here or in the other post where there's no actual evidence that she did, is any better than someone on a message board implying that Paul did something wrong by doing the same.
That's all. I don't see the reason for the infighting at all. Yoko and Paul seem to be getting along quite well these days, something that makes me very happy. I don't see the need to dredge up old conflict.
Okay. In that case, you're mis-interpreting me.
My take on this isn't that Paul was right to switch the credits, merely that he has the right. It was probably not a good decision of his to pursue the issue and to release such a long press statement about it back in 2002. I will defend his right to put his and John's name in whichever order he choses to, as long as it's on his own releases, but I won't say that it's a particularly wise decision to do so. If he wanted to preserve a good public image, he should have let it be. Trouble is, he doesn't see the "Lennon - McCartney" phrase as such a sacred cow that the rest of the world does, as he is too involved.
I also think that it wasn't a wise decision of Yoko's to address the issue back then. She could have neglected to comment, like John did with "Wings Over America". But as the "keeper of the Lennon flame", I can understand her interest in upholding status quo. It's an intriguing and many-faceted discussion, unfortunately the rest of the media aren't seeing all sides, which is why I'm trying to tie together the story. Now that McCartney seems to have accepted Yoko's way of crediting the composer of "Give Peace A Chance", that's a new twist on the story - and one that has already sparked negative comments in the Beatles fan community. My intentions for writing about it is merely to put the facts into the proper historic and chronological context, so that the commentators have a better understandings of the issues they are actually commenting on.
Post a Comment